2025 MLB Division & Awards Betting Picks: Who Will Surprise Us this Season?

Baseball season is already here, and anticipation is in the air! Fans are gearing up to place bets on their favorite teams and players, eager for the excitement that the 2025 MLB season will bring. With promising talent and a few surprises in store, this is the ideal time to make informed betting decisions. In this post, we’ll highlight some key betting picks for division winners and coveted awards that you won't want to overlook.

The countdown to the 2025 season is on, and let's take a closer look at what we can expect in terms of division predictions and individual accolades.

AL East Predictions

In the AL East, the Boston Red Sox stand out with odds currently at +350. This team is actively rebuilding, and recent roster changes with Garrett Crochet and Alex Bregman to provide them the momentum needed to dominate the division. The Sox also have the Big 3 prospects ready to break camp and take over with Kristian Campbell being the only of the 3 to break Opening Day roster, with Marcelo Mayer and Roman Anthony to come in later this season to add more excitement to the team and season.

However, the competition is stiff. The New York Yankees and Tampa Bay Rays are formidable opponents, bringing their own strengths to the table with lineups that excel in power hitting. Despite this, Boston's potential for a resurgence makes them an attractive pick for savvy bettors.

AL Central Predictions

Moving to the AL Central, the Detroit Tigers are turning heads with +270 odds. After years focused on developing young talent, this could finally be a breakout year for them. Last season, the Tigers’ average age dropped to 26.7 years, making them one of the youngest teams in the league.

While teams like the Minnesota Twins and Royals present challenges, the Tigers' combination of youngsters with amazing potential, like Riley Greene and Colt Keith, positions them as strong candidates for a division surprise.

AL West Predictions

In the AL West, the Seattle Mariners are looking promising with odds at +250. After finishing strong last season and reaching the playoffs, they have the combination of youthful energy and veteran experience. Their lineup features versatile players who can perform multiple roles—such as JRod and Randy—making it easier for them to adapt to game situations.

The Houston Astros remain the team to beat in this division, yet trading Kyle Tucker and getting rookie Opening Day starter Cam Smith to replace him in the lineup. The Mariners' pitching to exceed expectations positions them as an intriguing option for bettors eager for a value pick.

NL East Predictions

On the National League front, the Atlanta Braves have slim odds of +110. Their lineup is stacked, showcasing both depth and versatility. Players like Ronald Acuña Jr. coming back soon, along with superstars in Matt Olson, Austin Riley and Ozzie Albies, combined with a pitching staff of NL CY Young Chris Sale paring up with Spencer Strider and Spencer Schwellenbach that boasted a collective 3.50 ERA last season, place them as frontrunners for the NL East title.

While the New York Mets added the new $765 Million dollar man Juan Soto along with Lindor and Alonso for a competitive division this year and years to come. With Philadelphia Phillies being the reigning champs and capable challengers, Atlanta's cohesive team chemistry will likely support their pursuit of another successful season.

NL Central Predictions

The Cincinnati Reds are emerging as a compelling pick with +650 odds for the NL Central with first year manager Terry Francona. If they harness their young talent effectively, betting on them could yield significant returns. For instance, Elly and McClain represent a fresh approach to offense and defense, blending youth with experience. This lineup has the potential to really produce paired with a strong rotation with Hunter Greene, Brady Singer and Nick Lodolo, also they have 2 MLB ready arms in the minors with Rhett Lowder and 1st round pick of 2024 in Chase Burns if they need more pitching down the stretch of the season.

While the Cubs are always a threat,with adding Kyle Tucker to the Cubs already playoff ready roster, the Reds’ potential growth will surprise many this year.

NL West Predictions

In the NL West, the Los Angeles Dodgers are heavily favored at -500. Their historical investments in talent provide them with the depth necessary to deal with injuries and perform under pressure. Adding multiple superstars this off-season coming off a World Series championship, Blake Snell and Roki Sasaki filling into that already strong rotation and endless lineup of star power.

However, if the San Diego Padres, possessing stars like Fernando Tatis Jr. and Jackson Merrill can come together to put together another playoff run in 2025, Arizona is another

AL Most Valuable Player (MVP)

For the AL MVP race, Bobby Witt Jr. is a standout at +450. His potential is apparent, and should he elevate his performance, he could lead his team into playoff contention. With a 30-30 season last year along with a batting title with a .332 AVG , fans are eager to see what’s next this year and will Aaron Judge stay healthy to keep this a close race?

Keep an eye on Wyatt Langford as a surprising dark horse at +4000. If he can sharpen his skills like he did this Spring Training ,he could emerge as a contender.

NL Most Valuable Player (MVP)

In the NL, Shohei Ohtani is the reigning favorite at +170. His dual-threat capability as both a dominant pitcher coming back this year at some point and the best hitter in baseball last year makes him a perennial contender as long as he stays healthy. Last season alone, he recorded the first ever and most likely only player to have 54 HRs, 130 RBIs, 59 SBs and 134 Runs with a .310 AVG.

Meanwhile, Corbin Carroll, at +2200, is another name to watch. If he capitalizes on his speed and hitting ability early in the season, he could become a strong contender for the MVP title.

AL Cy Young Award

Logan Gilbert is an intriguing candidate for the AL Cy Young at +1400. With a 3.23 ERA last season and a 27% strikeout rate, he has displayed potential for greatness. Should he refine his control and consistency, a CY Young is in his future.

Gavin Williams, quietly positioned at +7000, presents a great sprinkle to keep an eye on throughout the season. If he builds on the promise he showed in Spring Training this year, he might just surprise audiences and steal the spotlight. This spring Williams numbers were 17.1 Innings with 26 K's and a 2.08 ERA.

NL Cy Young Award

For the NL Cy Young, Logan Webb sits at +3000. Known for his durability, he led the league the last two years with 216 and 204 innings pitched in the last 2 years, along with a 3.47 ERA. Consistency will be key for him this season.

Spencer Schwellenbach, at +3500, could capture attention if his development continues at its current pace. Look for him to potentially emerge from the shadows this year.

Rookie of the Year (ROY) Potential

Jacob Wilson leads the AL ROY race for me with +800 odds. His performance in the minors has excited fans and analysts alike with a top tier bat to ball contact. Cam Smith, lurking at +1200, should not be overlooked; his blend of speed and power could take the stage if he performs well early on with making the Opening Day roster and having plenty of play time available in Houston.

In the NL, Dylan Crews sits at +350 and is a name you should remember being teammates with 2024 NL ROY Paul Skenes at LSU. He showcased phenomenal abilities in college and minors, suggesting he’s ready for the big leagues and perform with a 20-20 possibility. Watch out for Matt Shaw at +425 as well, who started and already picked up his first hit in Tokyo Series.

Manager of the Year Predictions

Lastly, let’s highlight the managerial awards. In the AL, Alex Cora, at +750, could be the key figure turning the Red Sox from underdogs to contenders. His ability to keep the team focused and cohesive will be crucial throughout the season.

In the NL, Terry Francona stands at +550 odds. If the Reds manage to outshine expectations, his tactical decisions and leadership skills could easily lead him to the title of Manager of the Year.

Get Ready for an Exciting Season Ahead!

As the 2025 MLB season approaches, these betting picks serve as a fantastic starting point for fans eager to engage with the game. Whether you’re betting on the Red Sox to win the AL East or counting on Bobby Witt Jr. for the AL MVP, this season promises plenty of excitement and surprises.

It’s time to prepare for an exhilarating season of baseball! May your bets be successful, and enjoy the thrilling ride ahead!!! Happy Opening Day!!